A stormy night in Ohio set the stage for another unforgettable chapter in the ‘Hell is Real’ rivalry, as the Columbus Crew clawed back from a disastrous start to defeat FC Cincinnati 4-2 at TQL Stadium. In a match brimming with drama, tactical swings, and individual brilliance, Columbus turned a nightmare opening into an emphatic statement win that could reshape the Eastern Conference race.
A Lightning Start That Fizzled Out
When kickoff was delayed by an hour due to severe weather, the question was whether the electric atmosphere would survive the pause. Any doubts vanished just 39 seconds into the match when Cincinnati’s Pavel Bucha smashed home a Lukas Engel cutback, sending the home crowd into rapture. It was the second-fastest goal ever scored in this fierce Ohio derby, underscoring just how dialed in Pat Noonan’s men seemed from the outset.
Their early dominance didn’t stop there. In the fifth minute, Evander Da Silva Ferreira — one of the league’s most lethal threats from distance — collected a rebound from a blocked shot and launched a rocket from well outside the box, doubling Cincinnati’s lead. It was Evander’s 13th goal of the season, and remarkably, his eighth from outside the penalty area — a testament to both his technique and the Crew’s early defensive disorganization.
For Columbus fans, it looked like a long night ahead. But for all of FCC’s fireworks, the script was only half-written.
Nagbe Leads the Fightback
Great rivalries often hinge on pivotal moments and leaders who refuse to let a match slip away. In the 43rd minute, Columbus captain Darlington Nagbe seized that mantle. With Cincinnati’s midfield pressing high, Nagbe broke lines with a driving run that cracked open the defense. Spotting Ibrahim Aliyu in acres of space on the right, Nagbe’s pass forced the defense to scramble. When Aliyu fed Diego Rossi at the top of the box, the Crew’s star attacker rifled a shot beyond Roman Celentano to breathe life into Columbus’ hopes.
Then came the gut punch for Cincinnati: deep in first-half stoppage time, Max Arfsten found a pocket of space and unleashed a strike that deflected cruelly off Brian Anunga, wrong-footing Celentano to make it 2-2. The equalizer didn’t just change the scoreline — it flipped the momentum entirely.
Turning the Screws After the Break
Emerging from halftime, the Crew refused to relinquish their grip. Rossi, who had tormented FCC’s backline, engineered more chaos in the 59th minute when his driving cross forced an awkward intervention from Miles Robinson. The Cincinnati defender’s attempted clearance sliced into his own net, capping an astonishing turnaround that was part Columbus quality, part Cincinnati misfortune.
From there, Columbus dropped into a more compact shape, shifting to a five-at-the-back setup that suffocated Cincinnati’s favored long-ball channels. For a side built on stretching the field and punishing space in behind, the adjustment was a tactical masterstroke by Wilfried Nancy. FCC found themselves bereft of clear chances, as the fatigue of chasing the game compounded with every failed attack.
Taha Habroune’s stoppage-time dagger sealed the result. Exploiting a tired defense on the counter, the substitute coolly finished from the center of the box, a reward for Columbus’ ruthless game management.
What This Result Means
The 4-2 triumph extends Columbus’ unbeaten streak to five, with four wins in that span, signaling that the Crew are rounding into peak form just as the playoff race intensifies. Their resilience and ability to adapt tactically — especially in hostile environments — could prove decisive in the season’s final stretch.
Meanwhile, FC Cincinnati’s league-best points tally evaporated on a night when early fireworks gave way to second-half frailties. It was their first loss to Columbus since the 2023 Eastern Conference Final and snapped a four-game winning streak that had them looking like Supporters’ Shield favorites. With Philadelphia leapfrogging them after beating New York, Cincinnati must now regroup quickly — Inter Miami, with Messi and company, loom large in a crucial midweek clash.
Bigger Picture: A Rivalry That Delivers
‘Hell is Real’ continues to live up to its billing as one of Major League Soccer’s fiercest, most entertaining rivalries. Beyond the stunning goals and wild momentum swings, matches like this embody what the league needs more of: organic, regional passion with genuine stakes.
The Crew’s comeback highlights the value of veteran leadership in Nagbe, the importance of mid-game tactical adjustments, and the impact of attacking dynamism from players like Rossi and Habroune. For Cincinnati, the match raises questions about defensive depth and how they handle adversity — critical considerations if they want to be more than regular-season frontrunners.
Looking Ahead
Cincinnati hosts Inter Miami next, hoping to reassert their place atop the East. For Columbus, a trip to Nashville offers another chance to build momentum and prove that, no matter the storm or the scoreboard, they’re a team capable of rewriting their destiny over 90 minutes.
As the playoff race heats up, one thing is certain: the road to the top in the East runs through Ohio — and this rivalry will have plenty more chapters yet to be written.
Related post
Follow us — @undraftedus
