CINCINNATI — The night was set up for a statement. TQL Stadium was buzzing with 25,000-plus fans, fresh transfer arrivals flashing on the video board, and chants of “Brenner, Brenner, Brenner” echoing like a throwback to 2022. Instead, FC Cincinnati put in one of their flattest performances of the season, dropping a 1–0 decision to New York City FC that felt less like a speed bump and more like a gut check.
The Supporters’ Shield chase just got complicated. With six matches left in the regular season, Cincinnati slid from second to third in the table. Pat Noonan didn’t mince words postgame: “Poor performance tonight — that starts with me. We weren’t up for it.”
And he’s right — this was less about one unlucky bounce and more about a team that suddenly looked ordinary at the exact moment it needed to remind everyone they’re elite.
Everything about Saturday screamed opportunity. Cincinnati entered level with San Diego FC atop MLS, but with the edge to prove they’re still the team that lifted the Shield in 2023. NYCFC, scrapping for playoff positioning, brought hunger but not intimidation.
The first half unfolded like a dull sparring match. Cincinnati’s makeshift lineup, forced by injuries and fresh transfer turnover, struggled to stitch together meaningful sequences. Alvas Powell and Brad Smith, pressed into wingback duty after DeAndre Yedlin’s transfer and Luca Orellano’s injury, looked serviceable at best — but the attack was toothless. Three shots on target all night told the story.
New York smelled the opening. Pascal Jansen’s side wasn’t flashy, but they were disciplined. Alonso Martínez’s 55th-minute strike was the dagger — he torched three defenders in a straight-up footrace before slotting calmly past Roman Celentano. It wasn’t just a goal, it was a flex: NYCFC had the legs, the composure, and the intent. Cincinnati never found an answer.
When the collective struggles, it’s not fair to hang one guy — Noonan admitted “our whole team struggled” — but it’s hard not to point out how little spark came from Cincinnati’s front line.
Martínez’s goal changed everything. Until that strike, the match was cagey but balanced, like two teams shadowboxing. Once NYCFC scored, the script flipped: Cincinnati had no second act.
It wasn’t just conceding — it was how. Three defenders beaten in open grass at home, by a team fighting for eighth place, in a supposed Shield-chasing season. That sequence felt like a flashing neon sign: this version of FCC isn’t sharp enough.
The bigger picture hurts more than the 1–0 scoreline. Dropping from second to third in the Shield race with just six games left shifts the entire narrative. San Diego and others now see vulnerability.
Pat Noonan’s squad isn’t at full strength — Miles Robinson sidelined, Orellano missing, and new arrivals not yet integrated — but excuses don’t carry much weight when you’re supposed to be MLS’s elite. TQL is supposed to be a fortress. Instead, it’s starting to look like an open house.
The silver lining? Reinforcements are here. The transfer window brought back Brenner (on loan from Udinese, cue the fan nostalgia), Dominik Marczuk, Ayoub Jabbari, Samuel Gidi, and Ender Echenique. Only Echenique featured Saturday, but the depth chart looks very different heading into the stretch run. Once the pieces click, this team could go from flat to frightening in a matter of weeks.
The loss to NYCFC doesn’t doom Cincinnati, but it raises the stakes of every remaining match. Five wins in their last seven would’ve broken their single-season record — now that cushion is gone. Every dropped point is magnified in the Shield race and playoff seeding.
Next up? The Philadelphia Union on August 30, another heavyweight clash at TQL. Lose again at home, and the whispers about “maybe FCC peaked in 2023” will get louder. Win, and Saturday’s dud becomes a footnote.
Cincinnati had the stage Saturday night, the crowd, the roster hype, the chants. Instead, they played like a team searching for its identity mid-season rather than cementing itself as a Shield favorite. Alonso Martínez ran right through them — literally — and reminded MLS that the Orange and Blue are beatable, even in their own house.
It’s not panic time yet, but let’s be honest: this wasn’t just “a loss.” It was the kind of night that forces a reality check. Supporters’ Shield contenders don’t drop lifeless performances at home in late August.
The season’s final act is still unwritten, and Brenner’s return alone will keep fans buzzing. But for now, the only buzz coming out of TQL Stadium is the hum of frustration — and the sound of NYCFC walking out with all three points.
A better brand, built by Vaughn & Co. ©
